Indonesia's Home Affairs Minister Tito Karnavian has highlighted China's rapid economic transformation since 1998, contrasting what he saw on an early visit to Beijing and Shanghai with his observations on later trips.

Tito spoke on Friday, November 20, at a regional economic forum for Maluku and Nusa Tenggara in Jakarta. He recalled that while attending a command and staff college in New Zealand in 1998, China's potential rise was widely discussed, including a prediction that its economy would surpass that of the United States within 25 years.

That year, Tito and fellow students visited Beijing and Shanghai. He said he had doubted the prediction after seeing many people travelling by bicycle, impoverished neighbourhoods and a blackened river in Beijing, as well as old buildings in Shanghai. His doubts changed after several return visits, he said, as he observed rapid changes.

Tito said that by 2017, when he was Indonesia's national police chief, Beijing had developed to the point where it was almost like Washington, DC, and even better than New York. Recalling his most recent visit to New York in 2024, he said the city had changed little and raised concerns about homelessness and the cleanliness and safety of its underground transit system. He described the systems in Beijing and Shanghai as among the best.

The forum addressed economic growth in Maluku and Nusa Tenggara alongside environmental protection and public welfare. The regions have potential in marine industries and fisheries, agriculture, mining and tourism, with sustainable resource management needed to spread the benefits. Deputy Home Affairs Minister Bima Arya previously described the forum as a place for regions to exchange ideas and good practices. It is expected to produce policy recommendations on sustainable downstream development and economic competitiveness.